NapLab is supported by readers. When you buy with our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Data-Driven Mattress Comparisons

We use our objective testing data alongside expert subjective analysis to compare 200+ mattresses side-by-side.

Filter Options

Mattress Type

Price (Queen)

Average Price: $1,415

Overall Score

Average Score: 9.49

Best For

Firmness

Sinkage

Bounce

Thickness
Trial Period
Warranty
Shipping
Mattress Name
Show Filters

Winkbed

Winkbed Mattress Layers
9.95 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
9.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Couples

Saatva Classic

Saatva Material Layers
9.95 Overall Score
Type
Coil
Thickness
11.5"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium, Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Extremely High
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
9.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Couples

Diamond Flurry Lux

Diamond Flurry Lux Cooling Hybrid material layers
9.84 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
20 Years
Trial
120 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.3 Edge Support
9.6 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.7 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Cooling Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief

Winkbed Plus

Winkbed Plus Material Layers
9.82 Overall Score
Type
Plus-Sized
Thickness
14.5"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Low
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
8.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.4 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.9 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Pressure Relief Heavy People

Zenhaven

Zenhaven Material Layers
9.81 Overall Score
Type
Latex
Thickness
10"
Firmness Options
Medium, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Very Minimal
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.8 Edge Support
9.6 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Stomach Sleepers Natural & Organic Cooling Motion Transfer Response Time

Helix Midnight Elite

Helix Midnight Elite Material Layers
9.81 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
16"
Firmness Options
Medium
Sinkage
Very Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
10 Years
Trial
100 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
8.7 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.5 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Cooling Response Time Edge Support Pressure Relief

Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid

Amerisleep As3 Hybrid Material Layers
9.77 Overall Score
Type
Memory Foam Hybrid
Thickness
12"
Firmness Options
Medium
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
20 Years
Trial
100 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.6 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.4 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief Couples

Saatva Latex Hybrid

Saatva Latex Hybrid Material Layers
9.77 Overall Score
Type
Latex Hybrid
Thickness
12"
Firmness Options
Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Minimal
Bounce
High
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
10 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Back Sleepers Back Pain Natural & Organic Response Time Motion Transfer Edge Support Sex Off-Gassing

Nolah Evolution 15

Nolah Evolution 15 Material Layers
9.77 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
15"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium, Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
8.5 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.9 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.5 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Sex Pressure Relief

Helix Midnight Luxe

Helix Midnight Luxe Foam Layers
9.76 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
Firmness Options
Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Bounce
Low
Warranty
25 Years
Trial
101 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.4 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief

Nest Bedding Sparrow

Nest Bedding Sparrow Material Layers
9.76 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
12"
Firmness Options
Extra Soft, Medium, Firm
Sinkage
Very Deep
Bounce
High
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.5 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
10 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Sex Pressure Relief Company Heavy People Couples

Leesa Sapira Chill

Leesa Sapira Chill Material Layers
9.75 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm, Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Bounce
High
Warranty
10 Years
Trial
100 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
8.1 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
10 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.2 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Back Sleepers Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief

Elm Sleep Resort

Elm Sleep Resort material layers
9.75 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
15"
Firmness Options
Medium, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Minimal
Bounce
Low
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
180 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.7 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.5 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.5 Off-Gassing
10 Company
Best For
Response Time Pressure Relief Company

iSense Premier Hybrid

Isense Premier Hybrid Material Layers
9.75 Overall Score
Type
Adjustable
Thickness
13.5"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
10 Years
Trial
180 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.5 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.6 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.6 Off-Gassing
10 Company
Best For
Overall Response Time Pressure Relief Company Couples

Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid

Amerisleep As5 Hybrid Material Layers
9.73 Overall Score
Type
Memory Foam Hybrid
Thickness
14"
Firmness Options
Extra Soft
Sinkage
Moderate
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
20 Years
Trial
100 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
8.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.4 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.4 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Cooling Response Time Sex Pressure Relief Heavy People

GhostBed Flex

Ghostbed Flex Material Layers
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Thickness
11.5"
Firmness Options
Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Bounce
High
Warranty
25 Years
Trial
101 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.9 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.7 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Sex

Helix Plus

Helix Plus Material Layers
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Plus-Sized
Thickness
13"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Very Minimal
Bounce
Moderate
Warranty
10 Years
Trial
100 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.7 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.6 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Value Back Pain Response Time Edge Support Heavy People

Bear Elite Hybrid

Bear Elite Hybrid Material Layers
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Memory Foam Hybrid
Thickness
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Bounce
High
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.1 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Cooling Motion Transfer Response Time Sex Heavy People

Birch

Birch Material Layers
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Latex Hybrid
Thickness
11"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Bounce
Extremely High
Warranty
25 Years
Trial
100 Nights
Performance
10 Cooling
9.9 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.3 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.5 Company
Best For
Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Natural & Organic Cooling Response Time Off-Gassing

Saatva HD

Saatva Hd Material Layers
9.71 Overall Score
Type
Plus-Sized
Thickness
15.5"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Minimal
Bounce
Very High
Warranty
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
Performance
9.5 Cooling
8.4 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
10 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Back Pain Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Heavy People
{content}

Side-by-Side Comparisons

The following are our deep dive side-by-side mattress comparisons.