Data-Driven Mattress Comparisons
We use our objective testing data alongside expert subjective analysis to compare 200+ mattresses side-by-side.
Filter Options
Mattress Type
Price (Queen)
Average Price: $1,415
Overall Score
Average Score: 9.49
Best For
Firmness
Sinkage
Bounce
Thickness
Trial Period
Warranty
Shipping
Mattress Name
Winkbed
9.95 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Soft, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
120 Nights
Price
$1,499
$1,499
Performance
10 Cooling
9.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Couples
Overall Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Couples
Saatva Classic
9.95 Overall Score
Type
Coil
Coil
Thickness
11.5"
11.5"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium, Firm
Soft, Medium, Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Extremely High
Extremely High
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
365 Nights
Price
$1,695
$1,695
Performance
10 Cooling
9.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Couples
Overall Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Couples
Diamond Flurry Lux
9.84 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm
Soft, Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
20 Years
20 Years
Trial
120 Nights
120 Nights
Price
$1,899
$1,899
Performance
10 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.3 Edge Support
9.6 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.7 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Cooling Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief
Cooling Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief
Winkbed Plus
9.82 Overall Score
Type
Plus-Sized
Plus-Sized
Thickness
14.5"
14.5"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Low
Low
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
120 Nights
Price
$1,699
$1,699
Performance
10 Cooling
8.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.4 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.9 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Pressure Relief Heavy People
Back Pain Cooling Response Time Edge Support Pressure Relief Heavy People
Zenhaven
9.81 Overall Score
Type
Latex
Latex
Thickness
10"
10"
Firmness Options
Medium, Slightly Firm
Medium, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Very Minimal
Very Minimal
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
365 Nights
Price
$2,801
$2,801
Performance
10 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.8 Edge Support
9.6 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Stomach Sleepers Natural & Organic Cooling Motion Transfer Response Time
Overall Stomach Sleepers Natural & Organic Cooling Motion Transfer Response Time
Helix Midnight Elite
9.81 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
16"
16"
Firmness Options
Medium
Medium
Sinkage
Very Deep
Very Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
10 Years
10 Years
Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Price
$2,999
$2,999
Performance
10 Cooling
8.7 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.5 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Cooling Response Time Edge Support Pressure Relief
Cooling Response Time Edge Support Pressure Relief
Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid
9.77 Overall Score
Type
Memory Foam Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Thickness
12"
12"
Firmness Options
Medium
Medium
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
20 Years
20 Years
Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Price
$1,499
$1,499
Performance
9.5 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.6 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.4 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief Couples
Overall Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief Couples
Saatva Latex Hybrid
9.77 Overall Score
Type
Latex Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Thickness
12"
12"
Firmness Options
Medium-Firm
Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Minimal
Minimal
Bounce
High
High
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
365 Nights
Price
$1,866
$1,866
Performance
9.5 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
10 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Overall Back Sleepers Back Pain Natural & Organic Response Time Motion Transfer Edge Support Sex Off-Gassing
Overall Back Sleepers Back Pain Natural & Organic Response Time Motion Transfer Edge Support Sex Off-Gassing
Nolah Evolution 15
9.77 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
15"
15"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium, Firm
Soft, Medium, Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
120 Nights
Price
$1,999
$1,999
Performance
10 Cooling
8.5 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.9 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.5 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Sex Pressure Relief
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Cooling Response Time Sex Pressure Relief
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.76 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
14"
Firmness Options
Medium-Firm
Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Moderate
Bounce
Low
Low
Warranty
25 Years
25 Years
Trial
101 Nights
101 Nights
Price
$1,898
$1,898
Performance
9.5 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.4 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief
Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Motion Transfer Pressure Relief
Nest Bedding Sparrow
9.76 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
12"
12"
Firmness Options
Extra Soft, Medium, Firm
Extra Soft, Medium, Firm
Sinkage
Very Deep
Very Deep
Bounce
High
High
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
365 Nights
Price
$1,812
$1,812
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.5 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
10 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Sex Pressure Relief Company Heavy People Couples
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Sex Pressure Relief Company Heavy People Couples
Leesa Sapira Chill
9.75 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
14"
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm, Firm
Soft, Medium-Firm, Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Moderate
Bounce
High
High
Warranty
10 Years
10 Years
Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Price
$1,799
$1,799
Performance
10 Cooling
8.1 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
10 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.2 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Back Sleepers Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief
Back Sleepers Cooling Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief
Elm Sleep Resort
9.75 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
15"
15"
Firmness Options
Medium, Slightly Firm
Medium, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Minimal
Minimal
Bounce
Low
Low
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
180 Nights
180 Nights
Price
$1,199
$1,199
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.7 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.5 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.5 Off-Gassing
10 Company
Best For
Response Time Pressure Relief Company
Response Time Pressure Relief Company
iSense Premier Hybrid
9.75 Overall Score
Type
Adjustable
Adjustable
Thickness
13.5"
13.5"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Soft, Medium, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Deep
Deep
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
10 Years
10 Years
Trial
180 Nights
180 Nights
Price
$2,999
$2,999
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.5 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.6 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.6 Off-Gassing
10 Company
Best For
Overall Response Time Pressure Relief Company Couples
Overall Response Time Pressure Relief Company Couples
Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid
9.73 Overall Score
Type
Memory Foam Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Thickness
14"
14"
Firmness Options
Extra Soft
Extra Soft
Sinkage
Moderate
Moderate
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
20 Years
20 Years
Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Price
$2,199
$2,199
Performance
10 Cooling
8.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.4 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
9.4 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Cooling Response Time Sex Pressure Relief Heavy People
Side Sleepers Cooling Response Time Sex Pressure Relief Heavy People
GhostBed Flex
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Thickness
11.5"
11.5"
Firmness Options
Medium-Firm
Medium-Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Moderate
Bounce
High
High
Warranty
25 Years
25 Years
Trial
101 Nights
101 Nights
Price
$1,687
$1,687
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.8 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.9 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.7 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Sex
Side Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Response Time Sex
Helix Plus
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Plus-Sized
Plus-Sized
Thickness
13"
13"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Very Minimal
Very Minimal
Bounce
Moderate
Moderate
Warranty
10 Years
10 Years
Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Price
$1,124
$1,124
Performance
9.5 Cooling
9.7 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.6 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Value Back Pain Response Time Edge Support Heavy People
Value Back Pain Response Time Edge Support Heavy People
Bear Elite Hybrid
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Memory Foam Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Thickness
14"
14"
Firmness Options
Soft, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Soft, Medium-Firm, Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Moderate
Bounce
High
High
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
120 Nights
120 Nights
Price
$1,499
$1,499
Performance
10 Cooling
10 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.1 Edge Support
9.8 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
9.8 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Cooling Motion Transfer Response Time Sex Heavy People
Side Sleepers Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Cooling Motion Transfer Response Time Sex Heavy People
Birch
9.72 Overall Score
Type
Latex Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Thickness
11"
11"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Moderate
Moderate
Bounce
Extremely High
Extremely High
Warranty
25 Years
25 Years
Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Price
$1,599
$1,599
Performance
10 Cooling
9.9 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
9.3 Edge Support
9.7 Sex
9.5 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.5 Company
Best For
Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Natural & Organic Cooling Response Time Off-Gassing
Back Sleepers Stomach Sleepers Back Pain Natural & Organic Cooling Response Time Off-Gassing
Saatva HD
9.71 Overall Score
Type
Plus-Sized
Plus-Sized
Thickness
15.5"
15.5"
Firmness Options
Slightly Firm
Slightly Firm
Sinkage
Minimal
Minimal
Bounce
Very High
Very High
Warranty
Lifetime
Lifetime
Trial
365 Nights
365 Nights
Price
$2,801
$2,801
Performance
9.5 Cooling
8.4 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
10 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.8 Company
Best For
Back Pain Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Heavy People
Back Pain Response Time Edge Support Sex Pressure Relief Off-Gassing Heavy People
{content}
Side-by-Side Comparisons
The following are our deep dive side-by-side mattress comparisons.
Avocado
Bear
Birch
Brooklyn Bedding
Casper
- Casper Model Comparison
- Casper Original vs. Casper Original Hybrid
- Casper vs. Brooklyn Bedding
- Casper vs. DreamCloud
- Casper vs. Ghostbed
- Casper vs. Helix
- Casper vs. Leesa
- Casper vs. Nectar
- Casper vs. Purple
- Casper vs. Saatva
DreamCloud
- DreamCloud vs. Premier vs. Premier Rest
- DreamCloud vs. Casper
- DreamCloud vs. Helix
- DreamCloud vs. Nectar
- DreamCloud vs. Purple
- DreamCloud vs. Saatva
- DreamCloud vs. Winkbed
Ghostbed
Helix
- Helix vs. Casper
- Helix vs. DreamCloud
- Helix vs. Purple
- Helix vs. Saatva
- Helix vs. Helix Luxe vs. Helix Elite
- Helix Midnight vs. Plus vs. Sunset vs. Dusk vs. Dawn vs. Twilight vs. Moonlight
Layla
Leesa
- Leesa Legend vs. Hybrid vs. Original vs. Studio
- Leesa vs. Casper
- Leesa vs. Loom & Leaf
- Leesa vs. Nectar
- Leesa vs. Purple
Loom & Leaf
Nectar
- Nectar vs. Nectar Premier vs. Nectar Premier Copper
- Nectar Hybrid vs. Nectar Hybrid Premier vs. Nectar Hybrid Premier Copper
- Nectar vs. Casper
- Nectar vs. DreamCloud
- Nectar vs. Ghostbed
- Nectar vs. Layla
- Nectar vs. Leesa
- Nectar vs. Purple
- Nectar vs. Saatva
- Nectar vs. Winkbed
Nolah
Octave
Purple
- Purple vs. Casper
- Purple vs. DreamCloud
- Purple vs. Ghostbed
- Purple vs. Leesa
- Purple vs. Helix
- Purple vs. Nectar
- Purple vs. Saatva
- Purple vs. Tempurpedic
- Purple vs. Winkbed
Saatva
- Saatva vs. Avocado
- Saatva vs. Casper
- Saatva vs. DreamCloud
- Saatva vs. Helix
- Saatva vs. Loom & Leaf
- Saatva vs. Nectar
- Saatva vs. Purple
- Saatva vs. Tempurpedic
- Saatva vs. Winkbed