When you buy with our links, we may earn a commission. See how we work with brands here.

Mattress Brand Comparision Tool

Quickly compare, sort, and filter all 101+ mattress brands we’ve tested to date with the ultimate table tool.

Best Mattresses Garage4
Brand NameOverall Score AveragePrice Average (Queen)Trial (days)Warranty (years)ShippingReturnsShips ToModels TestedTypes AvailableFirmnesses AvailableRead Review
5 Little Monkeys8.72$1,23710015$0$0USA1KidsMediumReviews
Amerisleep8.95$1,76710020$0$0USA8Latex Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Extra Soft
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Ashley Sleep7.89$1,116010$0No / Very limited returnsUSA6Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Avocado9.21$1,484100, 36510, 25$0$0USA
Canada
2Latex HybridMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Awara8.67$1,074365Lifetime$0$0USA5Latex HybridMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Bear8.50$1,269120Lifetime$0$0USA6Foam
Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Beautyrest8.39$2,333100, 36510$0$0USA5Coil
Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Bedinabox8.72$1,12612020$0$0USA3Memory FoamMedium-FirmReviews
Bedstory6.61$3991000$0$0USA1HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Big Fig9.31$1,54912020$0$0USA1Plus-SizedSlightly FirmReviews
Big Mattress8.43$2,24910010$0$0USA1FoamMedium-FirmReviews
Birch9.15$1,799100Lifetime$0$99USA
Canada
2Latex HybridMedium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Boring8.93$79936510$0$0USA2HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Brentwood Home8.60$1,65536525$0$0USA1HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Brooklyn Bedding8.69$1,138120Lifetime$0$99USA
Canada
8Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Casper8.39$1,283100, 36510$0$0USA
Canada
15Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Classic Brands8.13$39910010$0$0USA
Canada
1Memory FoamMediumReviews
Diamond8.83$1,47912020$0$0USA5HybridSoft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
DLX8.52$1,349120Lifetime$0$0USA2HybridSoft
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Douglas9.20$1,03236520$0$0Canada3FoamMedium-FirmReviews
Dreamcloud8.62$1,061365Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
6Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Medium-FirmReviews
EcoSleep8.45$1,145120Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
3Latex HybridMedium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Ego Home7.57$47910010$0$0USA2Memory FoamMedium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Eight Sleep8.71$4,59910010$0$0USA
Canada
1SpecialtyMedium-FirmReviews
Emma8.81$81610010$0$0USA
Canada
7Hybrid
Memory Foam
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Endy8.80$1,09510015$0$0Canada2Foam
Hybrid
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Ghostbed8.82$1,32710120, 25$0$0USA
Canada
10Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
GhostBed8.82$1,32710120, 25$0$0USA
Canada
10Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Glacier9.05$1,099365Lifetime$0$0USA3Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Medium-FirmReviews
Habitat Furnishings8.38$2,29990Lifetime$0$99USA1AdjustableSoft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Hamuq8.23$99912015$0$0Canada1HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Happsy8.46$1,39912020$0$0USA
Canada
1Latex HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Helix8.97$1,941100Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
37Hybrid
Kids
Plus-Sized
Extra Soft
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
IKEA7.08$31918010$19No / Very limited returnsUSA4Coil
Foam
Hybrid
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Extra Firm
Reviews
iSense9.25$2,99918010$0$0USA2AdjustableSoft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Kingsdown7.92$1,24910010$0$150USA3Coil
Hybrid
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Kirkland8.08$99936510$0$0USA1HybridMediumReviews
Latex Mattress Factory8.49$1,05210010$0$99USA4Latex Foam
Latex Hybrid
Soft
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Layla8.86$1,22412010$0$0USA4Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Leesa8.93$1,573100Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
13Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Plus-Sized
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Logan & Cove8.73$1,33236515$0$0Canada6HybridMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Loom & Leaf8.75$2,69936525$0$99USA1Memory FoamMedium
Firm
Reviews
Lucid7.21$33910010$0$0USA1Memory FoamMedium-FirmReviews
Lull8.53$1,099365Lifetime$0$0USA3Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
My Green Mattress8.56$1,06136520$0$0USA1Latex HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Natural Form8.84$2,58310010$0$0USA1AdjustableMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Naturepedic8.47$3,39910025$0$0USA
Canada
2Coil
Latex Hybrid
Extra Soft
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Nectar8.66$1,134365Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
13Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Nest Bedding8.76$1,596365Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
8Foam
Hybrid
Kids
Latex Foam
Latex Hybrid
Extra Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Nolah8.89$1,796120Lifetime$0$99USA8Foam
Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Plus-Sized
Specialty
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Novaform7.32$47936520$0$0USA
Canada
3Memory FoamSoft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Novilla7.52$31410010$0$0USA2Hybrid
Memory Foam
Medium-FirmReviews
Novosbed8.87$99912015$0$0USA1Memory FoamSoft
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Octave8.79$1,19936515$0$0Canada3FoamMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Origin8.44$359365Lifetime$0$0USA2HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Personal Comfort8.88$2,95012020$0$0USA2AdjustableSoft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Pillar9.10$1,019120Lifetime$0$0USA1Memory Foam HybridSoft
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Plank8.70$1,299120Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
4Foam
Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Firm
Extra Firm
Reviews
PolySleep8.02$1,21530, 1005, 10$0$90USA
Canada
6FoamMedium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Polysleep8.02$1,21530, 1005, 10$0$90USA
Canada
6FoamMedium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Puffy8.54$1,961101Lifetime$0$0USA
Canada
7Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
MediumReviews
Purple8.31$2,19910010$0$150, $250USA
Canada
10SpecialtyMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Saatva9.24$2,784365Lifetime$0$99USA8Adjustable
Coil
Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Plus-Sized
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Sealy7.31$90790, 100, 36510$0$0, $175USA
Canada
7Coil
Hybrid
Memory Foam
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Extra Firm
Reviews
Serta8.45$1,69912010$0$0USA2Coil
Hybrid
Soft
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Sheets & Giggles8.84$1,79510010$0$0USA
Canada
1Latex HybridMedium-FirmReviews
Siena8.13$39118010$0$0USA2Foam
Hybrid
Medium-FirmReviews
Silk & Snow8.62$80636515$0$0USA
Canada
5Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Memory Foam
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Simba8.63$1,999100, 20010$0$0USA
Canada
2FoamMedium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Sleep EZ8.52$1,2799010, 20$0$99USA2Latex FoamSoft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Sleep Number8.13$1,10410015$0$250USA
Canada
1AdjustableExtra Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Firm
Extra Firm
Reviews
Sleep Science7.40$64936510$0$0USA1Memory FoamSlightly FirmReviews
SleepOnLatex8.16$1,29910010$0$0USA1Latex FoamMedium-FirmReviews
Spindle9.14$1,69936510$0$0USA
Canada
1Latex FoamSoft
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Stearns & Foster8.28$2,4999010$0$175USA2HybridSoft
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
SweetNight8.01$46110010$0$0USA6Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam
Memory Foam Hybrid
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Tempurpedic7.73$2,43290, 36510$0$0, $175USA4Memory FoamMedium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Titan8.76$1,311120Lifetime$0$99USA
Canada
4Hybrid
Plus-Sized
Medium-Firm
Firm
Reviews
Tuft & Needle8.62$1,39810010$0$0USA2Foam
Hybrid
Medium-FirmReviews
Vaya8.68$74910010$0$0USA2Foam
Hybrid
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews
Vesgantti7.12$29910010$0$0USA1CoilMedium-FirmReviews
Vibe7.38$39010010$0$0USA1Memory FoamSlightly FirmReviews
Westin8.26$2,495010$0No / Very limited returnsUSA1CoilMediumReviews
Winkbed9.15$1,599120Lifetime$0$0USA5Hybrid
Latex Hybrid
Memory Foam
Plus-Sized
Soft
Medium
Medium-Firm
Slightly Firm
Firm
Reviews
Zenhaven9.38$3,049365Lifetime$0$99USA1Latex FoamMedium
Slightly Firm
Reviews
Zinus7.28$29010010$0$0USA
Canada
2Hybrid
Memory Foam
Medium-FirmReviews
Zoma8.77$98610010$0$0USA4Foam
Hybrid
Memory Foam Hybrid
Medium
Medium-Firm
Reviews

About Derek Hales

Derek Hales

Derek Hales is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of NapLab. His insights and work has been featured on ABC's Tamron Hall Show, Freakonomics, CBS News, ESPN, Reader's Digest, Homes & Gardens, New York Post, CNET, & More. Derek has personally tested 440+ mattresses and began testing mattresses in 2014.

Popular Reviews & Guides

Close the CTA