When you buy with our links, we may earn a commission. See how we work with brands

Best Soft Mattress: Our Experts Test 360+ Mattresses

Derek Hales

Updated

Our experts have tested 360+ mattresses using our battery of objective & data-driven tests. Our best soft mattress list analyzes all of our performance tests, data, and research to highlight the best mattresses with a soft feel.

Best Mattress Throne

Top Pick

Support while sitting on the WinkBed

Winkbed

Winkbed is the highest-performing and best soft mattress we’ve tested to date (360+ tested). It earned perfect scores for cooling, pressure relief, edge support, and responsiveness.

The 8 Best Soft Mattresses

  1. Winkbed – Best Overall
  2. Saatva Classic – Best Coil
  3. Bear Elite Hybrid – Best Overall Runner Up
  4. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe – Best Affordable
  5. Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid – Best Memory Foam Hybrid
  6. Helix Moonlight Elite – Best Cooling
  7. Leesa Sapira Chill
  8. Nolah Evolution – Best Memory Foam Hybrid Runner Up
Mattress NameOverall ScoreTypeFirmnessPriceRead Review
Winkbed9.79HybridSoft (4), Medium-Firm (6), Slightly Firm (7)$1,499Review
Saatva Classic9.68CoilSoft (3.5), Medium (5.5), Firm (8)$1,795Review
Bear Elite Hybrid
9.26HybridSoft (4.5), Medium-Firm (6), and Slightly Firm (7.5)$1,578Review
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
9.24HybridSoft (4), Medium-Firm (6), and Firm (8)$1,399Review
Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid
9.24Memory Foam HybridExtra Soft (3.5)$2,149Review
Helix Moonlight Elite
9.15HybridSoft (4)$2,812Review
Leesa Sapira Chill
9.08HybridSoft (4), Medium-Firm (6), or Firm (8)$1,809Review
Nolah Evolution
9.01Memory Foam HybridSoft (4), Medium (5.5), or Firm (7)$1,595Review
YouTube video

Our Testing & Selection Process

360+

Mattresses Tested
To Date

43

Data Points Tested
On Each Mattress

102

Mattress Brands Tested To Date

Each best list is put through a customized performance analysis with specialized consideration given to our objective & data-driven performance tests. In addition, we consider mattress type, design, materials, value, price, and more.

Performance Testing Factors
Performance Testing Factors

For our Best Soft Mattress list, we based our selections on the best-scoring mattresses, according to our battery of testing and formulaic-driven scoring.

Our tests analyze performance across 8 critical factors, including cooling, motion transfer, response time, edge support, sex, pressure relief, off-gassing, and company. In addition, we also test sinkage and bounce (though these are not scoring factors).

Our tests include objective and quantifiable data whenever possible. In addition, we use subjective assessment supported by data to round out our testing process.

Our scores are based on mathematical formulas and equations that utilize inputs from our data-driven testing.

You can see our complete testing and scoring process here.

In choosing the best soft mattresses we looked at the totality of all of our tests, scores, data, and reviews to date. We analyzed this data alongside our established best mattress framework here.

In addition to achieving a high-performance score, all mattresses on this list have an extra soft or soft firmness (between 3.5-4.5 on the firmness scale).

When selecting the best soft mattresses, we’re looking at a combination of overall scoring performance, firmness, and US availability.

To be included within this list all mattresses:

  • Had to have a firmness between 3.5-4.5 out of 10, where 10 is the most firm.
  • Had to have a performance score of 9.01 or higher.
  • Had to be available for purchase within the USA.
  • Cannot be an adjustable mattress (we have a separate list for adjustables, see our best adjustable mattresses)

Our Testing Team

Derek Hales

Derek

Lead Tester

Kayla Hein

Kayla

Writer

Kyle Wandelt

Kyle

Tester

Nathan Lang

Nathan

Tester

Samantha Hales 2024 D

Samantha

Data Analyst

Winkbed Mattress

Winkbed Mattress Layers
9.79 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
9.6 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.1 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
9.4 Company

Best For

  • Outstanding pressure relief with 5.0″ of comfort material
  • Exceptional cooling performance
  • Lifetime warranty

Considerations

  • Trial period less than the average at 120 nights
  • 14″ thickness may be too tall to match some furniture sets
  • $49 exchanges, but returns are free

Our Verdict

The WinkBed is a 14″ hybrid made up of gel foam, poly foam, a pocketed coil unit, and a thick euro-top cover for a luxury feel. This is the mattress to beat for truly outstanding performance.

The Winkbed is available in three different firmness levels—softer (4), luxury firm (6), and firmer (7), where 10 is the most firm. This recommendation focuses on the Softer version.

The Winkbed offers a deep level of sinkage coming from its plush euro-top cover. We measured a sinkage depth that is 8% deeper than average yet the feel is still quite balanced in terms of the contour and hug around your body. Its bounce levels are also 12% high than average, aiding general ease of movement.

The Winkbed is the #1 best mattress by score that we’ve tested to date. In addition, it’s a fantastic value mattress.

Even as the highest-performing scoring mattress, its price is still just 2% more than the average mattress we’ve tested. At $1,499, this is only $27 more than the average while other luxury models can easily go for $3,000 to $4,000. So, if $1,499 is within your budget, this is the soft mattress to try.

Click here to read the full Winkbed review.

Type: Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Slightly Firm (7)

Winkbed Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Winkbed Sinkage Test
9.6

Motion Transfer Test

10

Response Test

Bounce Test

10

Edge Support Test

Winkbed Edge Support Sitting Test
FactorWinkbed
Overall Score9.79
Price (Queen)$1,499
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.38″
Sinkage – FeelDeep
Motion Transfer – Score9.6
Motion Transfer – Acceleration5.85 m/s²
Response Time – Score10
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.2 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered0.3 sec.
Bounce – Height9.91″
Bounce – FeelModerate
Edge Support – Score10
Edge Support – Sitting2.25″
Edge Support – LyingOutstanding
Sex – Score9.1
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness5.0″
Mattress Thickness14″
Off-Gassing – Score10
Off-Gassing – SmellNone
Off-Gassing – Days0 days
Company – Score9.4
Trial120 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Saatva Classic

Saatva Classic Material Layers
9.68 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
9.6 Motion Transfer
8.7 Response Time
10 Edge Support
9.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
10 Off-Gassing
8.8 Company

Best For

  • More traditional coil mattress feel with a plush quilted cover
  • Fantastic for couples—high bounce for sex and low motion transfer for sleeping with a partner
  • White glove delivery—ships uncompressed, includes in-home setup and removal of old mattress

Consideration

  • Costs 22% more than the average mattress
  • More traditional feel, some will love it, others may prefer more foam
  • $99 return fee

Our Verdict

The Saatva Classic is a traditional coil-on-coil mattress. In addition, you have the option of choosing between an 11.5″ or 14.5″ model. The price is the same for both and the comfort layer is same on both.

The Saatva is available in three firmness levels—Plush Soft (3.5), Luxury Firm (5.5), or Firm (8), where 10 is the most firm. This recommendation focuses on the Plush Soft version, which is Extra Soft compared to other soft mattresses on this list.

The feel of the Classic is distinguished by its use of foam-encased coils rather than dense poly or memory foam. It also uses a thick euro-top cover, which provides deep sinkage (2.40″) and adds to that soft luxury feel. Furthermore, bounce is extremely high due to the dual coil layers.

From a performance perspective, the Saatva Classic is nearly up there with the Winkbed, at 9.68. This puts it within the top 1% of all mattresses tested to date and is decidedly the best coil mattress we’ve reviewed.

A queen-size Saatva Classic costs $1,795, which is 22% more than the average mattress price (an increase of $323). No matter how you slice it, the Saatva Classic is an incredible soft mattress option for those who enjoy a traditional coil mattress experience.

Click here to read the full Saatva Classic review.  

Type: Coil
Firmness: Soft (3.5), Medium (5.5), Firm (8)

Saatva Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Saatva Classic sinkage test
9.6

Motion Transfer Test

8.7

Response Test

Bounce Test

10

Edge Support Test

Saatva classic edge support sitting test
FactorSaatva Classic
Overall Score9.68
Price (Queen)$1,795
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.40″
Sinkage – FeelDeep
Motion Transfer – Score9.6
Motion Transfer – Acceleration5.86 m/s²
Response Time – Score8.7
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.4 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered0.8 sec.
Bounce – Height14.67″
Bounce – FeelExtremely High
Edge Support – Score10
Edge Support – Sitting3.00″
Edge Support – LyingOutstanding
Sex – Score9.9
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness4.5″
Mattress Thickness11.5″
Off-Gassing – Score10
Off-Gassing – SmellNone
Off-Gassing – Days0 days
Company – Score8.8
Trial365 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Bear Elite Hybrid

Bear Elite Hybrid 2025 Material Layers
9.26 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
7.7 Motion Transfer
8.5 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.5 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
8.3 Off-Gassing
9.4 Company

Best For

  • Exceptionally good cooling performance
  • 5.0″ comfort layer creates 10/10 pressure relief
  • Excellent edge support for both sitting and lying

Considerations

  • Motion transfer was higher than average
  • Has high bounce is great for sex, but could be a bit much for some sleepers
  • Response time is only average

Our Verdict

The Bear Elite Hybrid is a 14″ hybrid mattress that utilizes a quilted cover, a comfort layer made of memory foam and poly foam, and a pocketed coil base. The cover can be upgraded to improve cooling, but cooling performance was already outstanding.

The Bear Elite Hybrid is available in three firmness levels — soft, medium-firm, and slightly firm (which Bear calls “firm”). This recommendation focuses on the Soft version.

This mattress has very deep sinkage and high levels of bounce. That deeper sinkage can be advantageous for side sleepers, while the high bounce creates a more active feel.

In our performance tests, this mattress earned an overall score of 9.26, ranking the mattress in the top 6% of all mattresses tested to date.

The Bear Elite Hybrid is $1,578 for a queen-sized mattress, which is slightly more expensive than the average mattress (a difference of 7%). Overall performance is fantastic, with a significantly better than average score.

Click here to read our full Bear Elite Hybrid review.

Type: Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (4.5), Medium-Firm (6), Slightly Firm (7.5)

Bear Elite Hybrid Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Bear Elite Hybrid 2025 Sinkage Test
7.7

Motion Transfer Test

8.5

Response Test

Bounce Test

9.5

Edge Support Test

Bear Elite Hybrid 2025 Edge Support Test
FactorBear Elite Hybrid
Overall Score9.26
Price (Queen)$1,578
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.66″
Sinkage – FeelVery Deep
Motion Transfer – Score7.7
Motion Transfer – Acceleration10.05 m/s²
Response Time – Score8.5
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.4 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered1.0 sec.
Bounce – Height10.70″
Bounce – FeelHigh
Edge Support – Score9.5
Edge Support – Sitting3.00″
Edge Support – LyingExcellent
Sex – Score9.5
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness5.0″
Mattress Thickness14″
Off-Gassing – Score8.3
Off-Gassing – SmellStrong
Off-Gassing – Days6 days
Company – Score9.4
Trial120 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Material Layers
9.24 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
8.2 Motion Transfer
9.6 Response Time
9.2 Edge Support
8.6 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
8.9 Off-Gassing
8.2 Company

Best For

  • Outstanding pressure relief with a balanced hybrid feel
  • Extremely fast material response
  • Exceptional cooling performance with cooling fibers in cover

Considerations

  • Motion transfer levels are a bit higher than ideal (9.06 m/s²)
  • $99 return fee and shorter trial period than average (120 nights)

Our Verdict

The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe is a 13.25″ thick hybrid that uses a thin quilted cover, a latex-like layer of poly foam, a layer of transitional poly foam, a pocketed coil unit, and a thin support foam base.

It is available in three firmness levels—soft (4), medium-firm (6), and firm (8), making it a good option for a wide range of sleeper weights, sleeping positions, and other personal preferences. This recommendation focuses on the Soft version.

The Aurora Luxe has more moderate levels of sinkage at 2.04″. The thinner cover limits this depth somewhat, but it more than makes up for it with cooling performance. Bounce is also more moderate than our previous picks and the mattress has a typical hybrid feel with balanced contour and hug.

In our performance tests, the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Hybrid has an overall score of 9.24, which ranks it in the top 8% of all mattresses tested to date. For specifically hybrid mattresses, it is also among the top 8%.

When it comes to price, the Aurora Luxe slides right under the average mattress. A queen-size costs $1,399, which is also 5% less expensive than the average mattress tested. In our view, the exceptional performance, most notably in cooling and pressure relief, and the cheaper-than-average cost make it a great value.

Click here to read the full Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe review.  

Type: Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (4), Medium-Firm (6), and Firm (8)

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Sinkage Test
8.2

Motion Transfer Test

9.6

Response Test

Bounce Test

9.2

Edge Support Test

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Edge Support Test
FactorBrooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
Overall Score9.24
Price (Queen)$1,399
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.04″
Sinkage – FeelModerate
Motion Transfer – Score8.2
Motion Transfer – Acceleration9.06 m/s²
Response Time – Score9.6
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.2 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered0.7 sec.
Bounce – Height8.96″
Bounce – FeelModerate
Edge Support – Score9.2
Edge Support – Sitting3.50″
Edge Support – LyingExcellent
Sex – Score8.6
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness4.3″
Mattress Thickness13.25″
Off-Gassing – Score8.9
Off-Gassing – SmellStrong
Off-Gassing – Days4 days
Company – Score8.2
Trial120 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid

Amerisleep As5 Hybrid Material Layers
9.24 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
7.9 Motion Transfer
10 Response Time
8.7 Edge Support
8.8 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
8.1 Off-Gassing
9.0 Company

Best For

  • Extra-soft feel (3.5 out of 10)
  • Exclusive side sleepers
  • Outstanding cooling performance with Amerisleep’s distinct “refresh cover”

Considerations

  • Motion transfer is high (9.65 m/s²)
  • Strong smell for 7 days
  • Trial period is only 100 nights

Our Verdict

The Amerisleep AS5 is a 14″ luxury hybrid. And by “luxury” we are referring to its above-average-thickness, material quality, pressure relief performance, and, of course, price. This is the first pick on our list to use (3″) memory foam in its comfort layer, which gives it an intense memory foam feel.

This is also our first pick with a singular firmness option. The AS5 Hybrid is extra soft with a 3.5 rating out of 10.

The AS5 has moderate sinkage (2.21″) despite its softer feel. However, heavier body parts like hips and shoulders will easily sink lower to a comfortable level. Bounce levels were moderately high (9.71″). Combined with the ultra-fast material response, the mattress is surprisingly extremely easy to move around on.

In our performance tests, the Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid scored a 9.24, which ranks it among the top 8% of all mattresses tested to date. For just our hybrid category, it is among the top 9%. That said, the price is another matter.

A queen-size AS5 Hybrid costs $2,149. This is considerably more expensive than the average mattress price (46% higher price). That being said, the AS5 Hybrid is among the best extra soft mattresses I’ve tested to date and a fantastic pick for sleepers looking for that soft feel.

Click here to read the full Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid review.

Type: Memory Foam Hybrid
Firmness: Extra Soft (3.5)

Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid sinkage test
7.9

Motion Transfer Test

10

Response Test

Bounce Test

8.7

Edge Support Test

Amerisleep AS5 Hybrid edge support
FactorAmerisleep AS5 Hybrid
Overall Score9.24
Price (Queen)$2,149
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.21″
Sinkage – FeelModerate
Motion Transfer – Score7.9
Motion Transfer – Acceleration9.65 m/s²
Response Time – Score10
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.2 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered0.3 sec.
Bounce – Height9.71″
Bounce – FeelModerate
Edge Support – Score8.7
Edge Support – Sitting4.25″
Edge Support – LyingExcellent
Sex – Score8.8
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness5.0″
Mattress Thickness14″
Off-Gassing – Score8.1
Off-Gassing – SmellStrong
Off-Gassing – Days7 days
Company – Score9.0
Trial100 nights
Warranty20 years

Helix Moonlight Elite

Helix Moonlight Elite Material Layers
9.15 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
8.8 Motion Transfer
8.2 Response Time
8.7 Edge Support
7.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
8.1 Off-Gassing
9.4 Company

Best For

  • Cooling cover facilitates fantastic cooling performance
  • Outstanding pressure relief thanks to high-quality and extra thick comfort layer
  • 15.5″ profile height helps create robust support

Considerations

  • Cost is nearly twice the average
  • Sex performance is hurt by low bounce
  • Slower than average response time

Our Verdict

The Helix Moonlight Elite is a 15.5″ hybrid mattress made of poly foam, microcoils, memory foam, and a pocketed coil base. It is equipped with a 2.25″ quilted cover that uses memory foam and has advanced cooling properties.

The Helix Moonlight Elite is available in a single firmness level — soft.

This mattress has extremely deep sinkage and low levels of bounce. This feel helps to create deep contour and hug, giving that all-encompassing feel. If you enjoy sinking deeply into your mattress, this is a great option.

In our performance tests, this mattress earned an overall score of 9.15, ranking the mattress in the top 12% of all mattresses tested to date. Considering just other hybrids, it places in the top 14%.

The Helix Moonlight Elite is $2,812 for a queen sized mattress, which is nearly double the average mattress price ($1,471). This mattress is clearly targeting the luxury market. And while it isn’t perfect, it offers luxury features with an incredibly soft feel.

Click here to read our full Helix Moonlight Elite review.

Type: Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (4)

Helix Moonlight Elite Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Helix Moonlight Elite Sinkage Test
8.8

Motion Transfer Test

8.2

Response Test

Bounce Test

8.7

Edge Support Test

Helix Moonlight Elite Edge Support Test
FactorHelix Moonlight Elite
Overall Score9.15
Price (Queen)$2,812
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth3.04″
Sinkage – FeelExtremely Deep
Motion Transfer – Score8.8
Motion Transfer – Acceleration7.64 m/s²
Response Time – Score8.2
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.4 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered1.4 sec.
Bounce – Height7.56″
Bounce – FeelLow
Edge Support – Score8.7
Edge Support – Sitting4.25″
Edge Support – LyingExcellent
Sex – Score7.9
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness6.0″
Mattress Thickness15.5″
Off-Gassing – Score8.1
Off-Gassing – SmellStrong
Off-Gassing – Days7 days
Company – Score9.4
Trial100 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Leesa Sapira Chill

Leesa Sapira Chill Measuring Materials
9.08 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
6.6 Motion Transfer
9.0 Response Time
9.5 Edge Support
9.4 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
7.2 Off-Gassing
9.4 Company

Best For

  • Top-tier cooling performance with phase change cover
  • Extremely supportive edge for sitting and lying
  • Fantastic sex performance mostly due to high bounce

Considerations

  • Price is 23% higher than the average hybrid
  • Very high motion transfer – highest on this list
  • Longer off-gassing duration (10 days)

Our Verdict

The Leesa Sapira Chill is a 14″ hybrid with a focus on cooling performance and is among the highest tiers offered in the Leesa mattress lineup. Its design includes a thick quilted cover with phase change materials, 2 layers of dense poly foam, and a transitional poly foam to ease the body into the pocketed coil base.

This mattress is available in three firmness levels—Soft (4), Medium-Firm (6), or Firm (8). This recommendation focuses on the Soft version.

The Sapira Chill provides moderate sinkage but high bounce. This gives it a feel that is both balanced and easy to move around on. The top two poly foam layers lean more towards feeling like memory foam with a more dramatic contour and hug. However, it’s not quite as intense as traditional memory foam.

In our performance tests, the Leesa Sapira Chill scored a 9.08. This ranks it among the top 16% of mattresses tested to date. The motion transfer and off-gassing categories drag its overall score down, but it is still a powerhouse in the other areas of performance.

At $1,809 it is 19% more expensive than the average hybrid. Even so, like the other picks, this price is more than justified for a soft mattress with this level of performance.

Click here to read the full Leesa Sapira Chill review.

Type: Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (4), Medium-Firm (6), or Firm (8)

Leesa Sapira Chill Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Leesa Sapira Chill Sinkage Test
6.6

Motion Transfer Test

9.0

Response Test

Bounce Test

9.5

Edge Support Test

Leesa Sapira Chill Edge Support Test
FactorLeesa Sapira Chill
Overall Score9.08
Price (Queen)$1,809
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.16″
Sinkage – FeelModerate
Motion Transfer – Score6.6
Motion Transfer – Acceleration12.55 m/s²
Response Time – Score9.0
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.3 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered1.0 sec.
Bounce – Height10.51″
Bounce – FeelHigh
Edge Support – Score9.5
Edge Support – Sitting3.00″
Edge Support – LyingExcellent
Sex – Score9.4
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness5.3″
Mattress Thickness14″
Off-Gassing – Score7.2
Off-Gassing – SmellStrong
Off-Gassing – Days10 days
Company – Score9.4
Trial100 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Nolah Evolution

Nolah Evolution 2025 Material Layers
9.01 Overall Score
Tested With Scoring System 1.3
10 Cooling
8.3 Motion Transfer
8.8 Response Time
8.6 Edge Support
7.9 Sex
10 Pressure Relief
8.3 Off-Gassing
8.2 Company

Best For

  • Cooling performance is fantastic
  • Deep sinkage and outstanding pressure relief
  • Extra thick 6.25″ comfort layer

Considerations

  • Imperfect edge support and low bounce led to a lackluster sex score
  • Motion transfer could be better
  • $99 return fee

Our Verdict

The Nolah Evolution is a 15″ memory foam hybrid mattress made of a quilted cover, memory foam, poly foam, and pocketed coils. A cooling cover can be attached, which provides a cool-to-the-touch feel. The mattress we tested included this optional pillow top (which increases the total height by 1″ inch, from 14″ without to 15″ with).

The Nolah Evolution is available in three firmness levels — soft, medium, and slightly firm. This recommendation focuses on the Soft version.

This mattress has deep sinkage and low levels of bounce. It distinctly has the feel of memory foam. If you love the deep sinkage and don’t mind the less responsive surface, this has a lot to offer.

In our performance tests, this mattress earned an overall score of 9.01, ranking the mattress in the top 21% of all mattresses tested to date.

The Nolah Evolution is $1,595 for a queen-sized mattress, which is 8% more expensive than average. If you are looking for a mattress that leans into the memory foam feel with a pillow top cover the Evolution is an excellent choice.

Click here to read our full Nolah Evolution review.

Type: Memory Foam Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (4), Medium (5.5), Slightly Firm (7)

Nolah Evolution Performance

10

Cooling Test

Sinkage Test

Nolah Evolution 2025 Sinkage Test
8.3

Motion Transfer Test

8.8

Response Test

Bounce Test

8.6

Edge Support Test

Nolah Evolution 2025 Edge Support Test
FactorNolah Evolution
Overall Score9.01
Price (Queen)$1,595
Cooling – Score10
Sinkage – Depth2.56″
Sinkage – FeelDeep
Motion Transfer – Score8.3
Motion Transfer – Acceleration8.88 m/s²
Response Time – Score8.8
Response Time – Mostly Recovered0.3 sec.
Response Time – Fully Recovered1.2 sec.
Bounce – Height7.77″
Bounce – FeelLow
Edge Support – Score8.6
Edge Support – Sitting4.50″
Edge Support – LyingExcellent
Sex – Score7.9
Pressure Relief – Score10
Comfort Layer Thickness6.3″
Mattress Thickness15″
Off-Gassing – Score8.3
Off-Gassing – SmellStrong
Off-Gassing – Days6 days
Company – Score8.2
Trial120 nights
WarrantyLifetime

Best Mattress By Category

Have a specific mattress type, sleeping position, feature, or firmness in mind? At NapLab we’ve ranked the mattresses we’ve tested in 24 different specialized best lists. These lists can help you identify the mattresses best suited to specific performance criteria.

You can also see our best mattress guide for our overall best-ranked mattresses.

Best by Type

Best in a Box

Best Hybrid

Best Memory Foam

Best Foam

Best Latex

Best Organic

Best Costco

Popular Reviews & Guides

Close the CTA